Home › Guide › Spare or finish?
The short answer: do what the crowd is calling for. When you win a bout, your beaten rival kneels and begs, and the crowd shouts its wish. If it wants mercy, Spare pays a bonus of 15% of the purse (at least 5 gold) and Finish pays nothing. If it wants blood, it is the other way round. If the crowd can't decide, either choice pays 8% (at least 3 gold). Neither choice is always better, because the crowd's wish changes from fight to fight.
The verdict has one longer-term effect, too: a rival you spare may come back for a grudge match, and a rival you finish may send a relative after you. This guide sets out the numbers behind all of it, checked against the game's own code, with worked examples.
You don't have to guess. On the victory screen, under your rewards, a line with a laurel shows the crowd's call, such as "The crowd wants MERCY!", "The crowd wants BLOOD!" or "The crowd can't decide!". The two verdict buttons also tell you the result before you press them: the choice that pleases the crowd shows "+N crowd gold", and the one that doesn't says "The crowd will boo". When the crowd is split, both buttons show the same smaller bonus.
If you pick Finish, you then choose a comic finishing move: booting your rival into the stands, spinning them like a top, the sandal of shame, and later ones unlocked at levels 15, 30 and 50. They are only for show. The crowd's gold is the same whichever finisher you pick.
The crowd's wish depends on the crowd meter (0 to 100) at the end of the fight. The game rolls a number from 0 to 99 for the bout. The crowd wants mercy if the roll is below 25 + 0.45 × crowd, is split if the roll is above 88, and wants blood otherwise. The split band is always rolls 89 to 99, so about 11% of verdicts are split whatever you do. The more you have warmed the crowd up, the more of the rest turns to mercy:
| Crowd meter at the end | Mercy | Blood | Split |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 (a cold crowd) | 25% | 64% | 11% |
| 25 | 37% | 52% | 11% |
| 50 | 48% | 41% | 11% |
| 100 (a full meter) | 70% | 19% | 11% |
So a quiet, grinding fight usually ends with the crowd baying for blood, and a showy one usually ends with it feeling generous. Even with a full meter, roughly one verdict in five still calls for blood, which is why "always spare" isn't the right rule. The percentages assume the game's roll is spread evenly from 0 to 99; for any single fight, just read the crowd's call on the screen.
The meter starts at 0 in each bout (the Blessing of Fortuna starts it at 25). In the current code, these add to it:
Some boss tricks work the other way: a bribe takes up to 40 points of favour, and the royal thumbs-down wipes the meter out.
The bonus is worked out from the gold the fight pays you (the purse), and rounded to the nearest whole coin:
Say a campaign win pays a purse of 100 gold and the crowd wants mercy. Spare pays 15% of 100 = 15 bonus gold, 115 in all. Finish pays no bonus, so you take 100. If the same crowd had been split, either choice would pay 8% of 100 = 8 gold, 108 in all. Here is the same sum for other purses:
| Purse | Matching the crowd (15%, min 5) | Split crowd (8%, min 3) | Against the crowd |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 | 15% = 3, raised to the minimum: 5 | 8% = 1.6, raised to the minimum: 3 | 0 |
| 60 | 15% = 9: 9 | 8% = 4.8, rounds to 5 | 0 |
| 100 | 15% = 15: 15 | 8% = 8: 8 | 0 |
| 250 | 15% = 37.5, rounds to 38 | 8% = 20: 20 | 0 |
Early on, the minimums matter most: on a small purse, pleasing the crowd is worth a good deal more than 15%.
After a campaign win, the verdict can set up a grudge:
A grudge waits at the arena gate after 3 to 7 more wins. Accepting it gives you a bout that pays a campaign win's purse where you stand, plus 25% more gold and experience. The grudge rival's strength matches your level, so it is a fair fight, not a free win. You can decline: it comes back 2 wins later, and the second time you turn it down it is gone for good. At most two grudges wait at once, and once two are waiting, no new ones are set up until you deal with one. Only campaign bouts create grudges. Tournaments and trials still have a verdict and its bonus, but no grudge follows.
Here is the arithmetic. A grudge is worth about 1.25 campaign purses. Finishing gives a 30% chance of one (0.30 × 1.25 = 0.375 purses on average) and sparing a 25% chance (0.25 × 1.25 = 0.3125). The difference is about 0.06 of a future purse. Going with the crowd is worth 0.15 of this purse straight away. So unless purses are about to grow a lot, the crowd bonus is worth roughly twice the grudge difference, and you also have to win the grudge fight to collect. Our conclusion: let the crowd decide, and think about grudges only when the crowd is split.
Hardcore is optional. It is the Emperor's oath: a new gladiator can take it, but an older save can't. Under the oath, losing a campaign, endless, cup or trial bout means the Emperor decides your fate. Practice bouts are safe. The fate screen shows your chance of mercy, which is:
Mercy chance = 30% + 0.45 × crowd meter + 1.2 × Charisma, kept between 30% and 90%, then rounded.
If the Emperor spares you, the healer takes 30% of your gold, rounded down: with 500 gold you pay 150 and keep 350. If he turns his thumb down, that gladiator falls for good and joins your list of the fallen. One exception: if you are signed in, or your save is linked to the cloud, a cloud save can't die. The Emperor spares you, and the healer still takes his fee.
This is why the crowd meter matters even in fights you might lose. The favour that sets the crowd's wish when you win also raises your odds of mercy when you lose.
Only loosely. In Rome the winner didn't decide. The official or patron who paid for the games gave the verdict, usually guided by the crowd, and a beaten professional was often let go alive (missio). The game hands the choice to you and turns the crowd's wish into gold. For the real history, with sources, see did gladiators fight to the death? and Roman gladiator types.
For winning the fight in the first place, see the strategy guide, and for the stats behind Charisma, see the four classes.
The daily arena challenge puts your verdict on a shareable result card, so you can compare it with friends who fought the same rival.
Play now, free Compare the classes
Beginner's guide · Strategy · Combat odds · Classes · FAQ · Gladiator types · Did gladiators fight to the death? · Name generator · Duel a friend · Daily challenge · Ghost duel · Patch notes · Home · Press kit · Privacy
How this page was checked: every rule and number was checked against the game as it stood on 30 October 2026.